FOR FILMS IN CHARGE OF CHANGE
directed by Sergio Zaciu
Whining Low, the debut film of Sergio Zaciu, portrays an illegal Russian immigrant in Texas who is torn between desperation and fear, moral principles and hopelessness. In her pursuit of dignity and financial stability, Svetlana finds herself involuntarily entangled in a complicated state of affairs that involves kidnapping, murder, Latin-American runaways and a reward.
In a remote village in Texas, Svetlana is striving to make ends meet to financially support her son in Russia. Her illegal status and naivety allow the gas station’s manager to pay her less and benefit from her silence. Nevertheless, in the right context, desperation leads to her getting caught in a series of risky situations.
Svetlana’s conflict with herself and the American system is powerfully captured by the Western-like atmosphere and setting. The clash between her moral standards and the struggle for survival fosters a dramatic and intense follow-up. In the end, in this fight, it’s the human instincts and desperation that overtake morals.
The short film’s well-balanced script allows for a thorough portrayal of the female protagonist. Slow-paced, meditative scenes are followed by dynamic, hurried events that move the story forward. However, despite several overly dramatic and prolonged actions, Whining Low’s overall tone is balanced, yielding place and time for empathy and reflection.
Together with the well-structured script, the short’s cinematography manages to capture the intensity of Svetlana’s inner conflict as well as her desperation. The cinematography is diverse enough to depict both her environment and struggle. From close-ups to wide angles, Whining Low manages to portray a woman engulfed by desperation, innocence, low morals, and context. The grainy look of the image, as well as the old-school country music, induces a vintage, yet atemporal atmosphere. Ultimately, the drama of a Russian immigrant overstaying her VISA in the USA is as relevant as it gets. On top of that, the addition of a runaway Latin-American character adds complexity to an already diverse microcosm.
Despite the qualitative script and quaint cinematography, Whining Low could have benefited from improvement in certain areas. For example, the sound design produces an unnatural tone, while the acting is at times unnecessarily dramatic and exaggerated. However, these flaws can easily be overlooked thanks to the compelling portrayal of Svetlana’s drama and general atmosphere.
Although it’s his first film, Sergio Zaciu managed to recreate an authentic, yet intense drama that’s highly relatable. The main character is depicted in a humane fashion, while the story raises awareness about the drama of illegal immigrants. In the end, Whining Low gives a glimpse of the world where the struggle for survival overpowers morality and innocence.